diff --git a/karbor/services/protection/checkpoint.py b/karbor/services/protection/checkpoint.py
index 91079753..c88ed2d4 100644
--- a/karbor/services/protection/checkpoint.py
+++ b/karbor/services/protection/checkpoint.py
@@ -354,8 +354,11 @@ class CheckpointCollection(object):
                                                           marker=marker,
                                                           sort_dir=sort_dir,
                                                           context=context):
-                date = datetime.strptime(key.split("/")[-3], "%Y-%m-%d")
-                checkpoint_project_id = key.split("/")[-2]
+                date_cursor = -2 if (prefix.find('by-plan') >= 0) else -3
+                project_id_cursor = -3 if (prefix.find('by-plan') >= 0) else -2
+                date = datetime.strptime(
+                    key.split("/")[date_cursor], "%Y-%m-%d")
+                checkpoint_project_id = key.split("/")[project_id_cursor]
                 if start_date <= date <= end_date and (
                         checkpoint_project_id == project_id):
                     ids.append(key[key.find("@") + 1:])
diff --git a/karbor/tests/unit/protection/test_checkpoint_collection.py b/karbor/tests/unit/protection/test_checkpoint_collection.py
index 7e3d83b4..6c968c35 100644
--- a/karbor/tests/unit/protection/test_checkpoint_collection.py
+++ b/karbor/tests/unit/protection/test_checkpoint_collection.py
@@ -69,6 +69,32 @@ class CheckpointCollectionTest(base.TestCase):
             project_id="fake_project_id_2", provider_id=provider_id_2,
             plan_id="fake_plan_id_2")), checkpoints_plan_2)
 
+    def test_list_checkpoints_by_plan_id_and_filter_by_start_date(self):
+        collection = self._create_test_collection()
+        date1 = datetime.strptime("2018-11-12", "%Y-%m-%d")
+        date2 = datetime.strptime("2018-11-13", "%Y-%m-%d")
+        timeutils.utcnow = mock.MagicMock()
+        timeutils.utcnow.return_value = date1
+        plan = fake_protection_plan()
+        plan["id"] = "fake_plan_id"
+        plan['provider_id'] = "fake_provider_id"
+        plan["project_id"] = "fake_project_id"
+        provider_id = plan['provider_id']
+        checkpoints_plan_date1 = {
+            collection.create(plan).id for i in range(10)}
+        timeutils.utcnow = mock.MagicMock()
+        timeutils.utcnow.return_value = date2
+        checkpoints_plan_date2 = {
+            collection.create(plan).id for i in range(10)}
+        self.assertEqual(set(collection.list_ids(
+            project_id="fake_project_id", provider_id=provider_id,
+            plan_id="fake_plan_id", start_date=date1, end_date=date1)),
+            checkpoints_plan_date1)
+        self.assertEqual(set(collection.list_ids(
+            project_id="fake_project_id", provider_id=provider_id,
+            plan_id="fake_plan_id", start_date=date2)),
+            checkpoints_plan_date2)
+
     def test_list_checkpoints_by_date(self):
         collection = self._create_test_collection()
         date1 = datetime.strptime("2016-06-12", "%Y-%m-%d")